Suu Kyi lacks ‘moral leadership’, says US diplomat as he quits Rohingya panel

US diplomat Bill Richardson resigned early yesterday from an Aung San Suu Kyi-appointed panel set up to ease communal tensions in Myanmar's Rakhine State and hit out at the Nobel Laureate for an "absence of moral leadership" over the crisis, reports AFP. In a statement that pulled few punches, the former US governor and one-time Suu Kyi ally said he could not in "good conscience" serve on the committee that would likely serve only to "whitewash" the causes behind the Rohingya exodus. Richardson also accused Suu Kyi of a "furious response" to his calls to help free two Reuters journalists arrested while reporting on the Rakhine crisis. Wa Lone, 31, and Kyaw Soe Oo, 27, were arrested in December and face up to 14 years in jail under the Official Secrets Act over the alleged possession of classified documents, purportedly relating to the army campaign in Rakhine that sparked the exodus.

The resignation deals an embarrassing public blow to Suu Kyi as her civilian government grapples with a crisis that has sent hundreds of thousands of Rohingya Muslim refugees fleeing into Bangladesh since August — and eviscerated her reputation as a defender of the downtrodden in the process.

The US State Department noted that Richardson, a retired senior official and former state governor, had joined the Myanmar board as a private citizen, but added that the Washington administration shares many of his concerns. “Governor Richardson’s decision to resign from the Rakhine Advisory Board, and the reasons he gave for doing so, are cause for concern,” spokeswoman Heather Nauert said.

Nauert said the board which Richardson joined was supposed to oversee implementation of recommendations made by a commission led by former UN secretary-general Kofi Annan. “The recommendations address critical actions needed to address longstanding, serious challenges in Rakhine State, including the underlying sources of recent violence and displacement,” Nauert said.

“Ultimately, the Burmese government and military have the authority to determine whether the Advisory Board will succeed in its mission.”

Richardson’s resignation also came after Myanmar and Bangladesh failed to meet a January 23 deadline to begin the complex and contested repatriation of refugees.

Nearly 690,000 Rohingya have fled a Myanmar army crackdown and crossed over to Bangladesh and many do not want to go back to Rakhine.

The UN and US have both accused the army and hardline militant Buddhist mobs of ethnic cleansing against the Muslim minority.

Inside Myanmar the Rohingya are widely regarded as illegal immigrants from Bangladesh even though many have lived there for generations.

“It is with great disappointment that I announce my resignation from the Advisory Board on Rakhine State,” a statement released by Bill Richardson’s office said after three days of talks in Myanmar.

“It appears that the Board is likely to become a cheerleading squad for government policy as opposed to proposing genuine policy changes that are desperately needed to assure peace, stability, and development in Rakhine State.”

He said he was “taken aback” by the disparagement of the media, the UN, human rights groups and the international community and alarmed by the “lack of sincerity” with which the issue of Rohingya citizenship was discussed.

Rohingya have been denied citizenship for decades in a discriminatory system that heavily restricts their rights and movement within Myanmar.

Richardson admitted the military still wields significant power but added that “the absence of Daw Suu’s moral leadership on this critical issue is of great concern”.

Meanwhile, Richardson was accused yesterday of a “personal attack” on Myanmar’s Aung San Suu Kyi after an excoriating takedown of the former darling of the global rights community as he resigned from a panel on the Rohingya crisis.

One-time Suu Kyi ally Richardson was one of five foreign members handpicked by Myanmar’s civilian leader to serve on the committee.

A Myanmar government spokesman has hit back, accusing the former New Mexico governor of overstepping the mark in his stinging resignation letter. “He should review himself over his personal attack against our State Counsellor,” government spokesman Zaw Htay told AFP, referring to Suu Kyi’s official title.

“We understand his emotion about the two Reuters correspondents. However, he needs to understand, rather than blame the Myanmar nation and the State Counsellor.”

Zaw Htay said the issue of the arrests was beyond Richardson’s mandate and he should not have brought it up at his meeting with Suu Kyi. The heated discussion left Myanmar’s leader “quivering” with rage, Richardson told the New York Times. “If she had been a little closer to me, she might have hit me, she was so furious,” the paper quoted Richardson as saying.

 

Suu Kyi lacks moral leadership, says US diplomat as he quits Rohingya panel

US diplomat Bill Richardson resigned early yesterday from an Aung San Suu Kyi-appointed panel set up to ease communal tensions in Myanmars Rakhine State and hit out at the Nobel Laureate for an absence of moral leadership over the crisis, reports AFP. In a statement that pulled few punches, the former US governor and one-time Suu Kyi ally said he could not in good conscience serve on the committee that would likely serve only to whitewash the causes behind the Rohingya exodus. Richardson also accused Suu Kyi of a furious response to his calls to help free two Reuters journalists arrested while reporting on the Rakhine crisis. Wa Lone, 31, and Kyaw Soe Oo, 27, were arrested in December and face up to 14 years in jail under the Official Secrets Act over the alleged possession of classified documents, purportedly relating to the army campaign in Rakhine that sparked the exodus. The resignation deals an embarrassing public blow to Suu Kyi as her civilian government grapples with a crisis that has sent hundreds of thousands of Rohingya Muslim refugees fleeing into Bangladesh since August and eviscerated her reputation as a defender of the downtrodden in the process. The US State Department noted that Richardson, a retired senior official and former state governor, had joined the Myanmar board as a private citizen, but added that the Washington administration shares many of his concerns. Governor Richardsons decision to resign from the Rakhine Advisory Board, and the reasons he gave for doing so, are cause for concern, spokeswoman Heather Nauert said. Nauert said the board which Richardson joined was supposed to oversee implementation of recommendations made by a commission led by former UN secretary-general Kofi Annan. The recommendations address critical actions needed to address longstanding, serious challenges in Rakhine State, including the underlying sources of recent violence and displacement, Nauert said. Ultimately, the Burmese government and military have the authority to determine whether the Advisory Board will succeed in its mission. Richardsons resignation also came after Myanmar and Bangladesh failed to meet a January 23 deadline to begin the complex and contested repatriation of refugees. Nearly 690,000 Rohingya have fled a Myanmar army crackdown and crossed over to Bangladesh and many do not want to go back to Rakhine. The UN and US have both accused the army and hardline militant Buddhist mobs of ethnic cleansing against the Muslim minority. Inside Myanmar the Rohingya are widely regarded as illegal immigrants from Bangladesh even though many have lived there for generations. It is with great disappointment that I announce my resignation from the Advisory Board on Rakhine State, a statement released by Bill Richardsons office said after three days of talks in Myanmar. It appears that the Board is likely to become a cheerleading squad for government policy as opposed to proposing genuine policy changes that are desperately needed to assure peace, stability, and development in Rakhine State. He said he was taken aback by the disparagement of the media, the UN, human rights groups and the international community and alarmed by the lack of sincerity with which the issue of Rohingya citizenship was discussed. Rohingya have been denied citizenship for decades in a discriminatory system that heavily restricts their rights and movement within Myanmar. Richardson admitted the military still wields significant power but added that the absence of Daw Suus moral leadership on this critical issue is of great concern. Meanwhile, Richardson was accused yesterday of a personal attack on Myanmars Aung San Suu Kyi after an excoriating takedown of the former darling of the global rights community as he resigned from a panel on the Rohingya crisis. One-time Suu Kyi ally Richardson was one of five foreign members handpicked by Myanmars civilian leader to serve on the committee. A Myanmar government spokesman has hit back, accusing the former New Mexico governor of overstepping the mark in his stinging resignation letter. He should review himself over his personal attack against our State Counsellor, government spokesman Zaw Htay told AFP, referring to Suu Kyis official title. We understand his emotion about the two Reuters correspondents. However, he needs to understand, rather than blame the Myanmar nation and the State Counsellor. Zaw Htay said the issue of the arrests was beyond Richardsons mandate and he should not have brought it up at his meeting with Suu Kyi. The heated discussion left Myanmars leader quivering with rage, Richardson told the New York Times. If she had been a little closer to me, she might have hit me, she was so furious, the paper quoted Richardson as saying.